HOA Dumped Thousands of Fish in My Pond — Then I Discovered They Were Worth $600K

HOA Dumped Thousands of Fish in My Pond — Then I Discovered They Were Worth $600K

Chapter 30

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Evelyn Price called me after the homeowners received a notice that the expansion review had been delayed. She said the association's board had described the delay as outside interference and blamed it partly on my refusal to cooperate. But residents were beginning to ask why a project presented as nearly approved suddenly required extensive investigation into historical breeding rights. Several had requested an accounting of how much association money had been spent on the corridor before the fish transfer occurred.

"People are upset," Evelyn told me. "Not because you have fish. Because they don't understand why our board spent money to make these decisions without bringing us into the conversation."

"You deserve answers from the people who made the decisions," I said. "But I can't tell you what happened inside their meetings. I can tell you what they did on my land."

"That's a start," she replied.

I didn't want to turn the residents of Silver Ridge into enemies. Some of them had brought food after a bad winter storm; others had helped me catch a neighbor's loose horses years earlier. Most were people who worked, raised families, and trusted the association to handle matters they didn't have time to examine personally. I saw no reason to punish them for Karen's decisions, and I had little interest in being the face of a fight over somebody else's house values.

At Daniel's suggestion, we prepared a factual statement describing the transfer, the disputed invoice, the court's ruling, and the ongoing agency review. It avoided speculation about criminal conduct or predictions about how the development would end. We sent it to homeowners who requested information and referred questions about the association's finances to their own board and auditors. When a neighbor thanked me for not turning the dispute into a public shouting match, I told her I was simply too old to enjoy shouting as a substitute for answers.

Meanwhile, the first draft of our Riverstone management agreement came back covered in comments. The trust wanted its historical genetic line protected, and Tom wanted sufficient operating flexibility to build a viable business. I wanted a clear division between the land I owned, the animals to which the trust could trace valid rights, and any offspring we might produce under a future license. We also needed written standards for what happened if the arrangement ended or if regulatory approval was withdrawn.

The discussions were more difficult than I had expected. Martin cared deeply about preserving the program's records and resisted anything that sounded like turning decades of work into a brand name. I cared about not investing my retirement savings in equipment I might be unable to use if somebody changed their mind. Tom cared about whether the cost of compliance would leave enough income for a business to survive. Daniel had the unpleasant job of fitting all those concerns into a contract that people could read without guessing.

News in the same category

HOA Dumped Thousands of Fish in My Pond — Then I Discovered They Were Worth $600K

40 Part